“Terrible” Steeler Eggs

This is a simple deviled eggs recipe that I use when I bring eggs to any holiday party. Last year I put them on a Steelers’ logo plate for the Super Bowl, and every time someone ate one, the Steelers scored a touchdown 🙂 I like the more basic recipes like this one for eggs because the more stuff you add, the more likely that someone isn’t going to like them (like relish for instance).

1 dozen eggs
1/2 c. mayo (this is a starting point for people who don’t love mayo, by the end I may use up to a cup depending on the consistency)
1 teaspoon mustard (I use the mustard pretty sparingly)

1/4 of a red onion (finely chopped)

1 teaspoon teaspoons of garlic powder (you can use minced garlic here)

Salt and Pepper
Smoky Paprika (The smoke make all the difference)

Dill Weed

– Place eggs in pan with water to cover plus one inch. I usually start with lukewarm water in the pan.
– Once the water comes to a boil, cook for 15 minutes. Turn off the heat and leave the eggs for 15-30 minutes.
– Run cold water over the eggs and peel them. Shake them in the pan while the water is running to start cracking the shells.
– Cut eggs lengthwise and put yolks in a bowl with the mustard and mayo.
– Mix well and add more mayo as necessary to make the mixture really creamy.

– Add onion and garlic, salt and pepper, and a couple dashes of dill.
– Return filling to the eggs and garnish with paprika and more pepper
Linda’s Notes:
– I use a LOT of mayonnaise in these eggs. It’s probably even more than a cup. It looks a little scary when you’re dumping it all in, but it makes them creamy and have that vinegary taste without using more mustard.
– To make them appear to be more like Steeler’s Eggs, I use a lot of freshly-ground pepper on top with the paprika
– Hard-cooking the eggs in the oven is a great alternative to boiling

Leave a comment